Skip to main content

Why Not a "Dazzling Offense"?

It has been a while since I've published anything in an actual newspaper. I'll call the Chicago Defender to see if I can get a copy of my rant about Michael Eric Dyson's book. Maybe next I'll be in the Detroit Upside Your Head paper. The article has also been linked by BlackAmericaToday and Politopics.


Here's the version published in Black America Today on Christmas Day, 2005, and reposted now because of an Internet discussion.

By Casey Lartigue
December 25, 2005

Known for his outspoken tough love, Bill Cosby once publicly admonished a young black student from the University of the District of Columbia.  The young man hoped for a promotion at his Drug Enforcement Administration job after he got his degree, but he was worried.  He told Cosby, "It just gets scary sometimes.  But if I'm put on a pedestal... I'm afraid I'll fail.  It's scary."

"What is so scary is that you aren't trying," Cosby shot back.  "This is a time for you to grasp what you can. Go up, man... Don't just stay where you are."

This didn't happen at last year's 50th anniversary of the Brown v. Board of Education decision, where Cosby caused a frenzy by criticizing the parenting skills of low-income blacks.  This exchange happened back in 1983 when he was speaking at a two-day conference in Washington called "A National Assessment Conference on Education and the Future of Black Americans: 1983 and Beyond."  Cosby, however, gave the conference its unofficial theme: black youngsters needed to start taking advantage of available opportunities.

If such a conference were held in 2005, it would likely be denounced as a mean-spirited affair where the black elite simply heaped blame on poor black kids.  The person most likely to denounce it would be Michael Eric Dyson, the fast-talking author and hip-hop professor at the University of Pennsylvania.  Dyson was among the first - and loudest - to condemn Cosby's tough-love comments, and he's put his thoughts together in the book Is Bill Cosby Right? Or Has the Black Middle Class Lost Its Mind?

For all of the bluster and anger about Cosby's comments and tone, Dyson's written a book that's utterly useless to the very people he claims to defend.  The book's dust jacket promises a "dazzling defense" of black life.  After reading the book, one can't help but wonder: Why not also offer a "dazzling offense"?

Is Bill Cosby Right? is the equivalent of a 288-page love note to a low-income black family in the process of getting evicted from their home.  It furthermore offers no practical advice. Dyson has a few good ideas, but he boxes himself in with too many categories and labels such as "Afristocracy" (professional and upper bourgeois blacks) and "ghettocracy" (those at the bottom).

On page after page, Dyson condemns the black elite for being ashamed of the black masses.

Although he could have ended his book with realistic and common sense advice, for whatever reason, Dyson doesn't.  His own life has reportedly been tumultuous, going from a middle-class childhood and boarding school education to becoming a teenage father and welfare recipient in his 20s to his current job as a tenured university professor. He would certainly seem qualified to advise people on how to overcome barriers to success, but all he does is scoff at Cosby without offering anything beyond a defense.

In contrast to Cosby's criticism of black criminality, Dyson seeks to "understand" the criminal. For instance, when Dyson was robbed at gunpoint in Detroit back in 1977, he said he and his would-be robber allegedly got into a conversation about why the young man was trying to rob him. The dark forces of institutional racism explain why they were there, as robber and victim.  It is then understandable that Dyson literally swoons when discussing Cosby's 1976 dissertation bashing institutional racism.

Another problem with Is Bill Cosby Right? is Dyson's tendency to romanticize the ghetto. Vices are denied or turned into virtues.  That may be a clever debating point on his university campus, but what is a parent struggling with a 14-year-old reading at the third grade level supposed to do with this sophistry?

Over his four-decade career, Bill Cosby has made it known that he believes racial barriers exist. But, after giving his own money and time for years in an effort to help blacks, Cosby may be telling people to stand up because he is tired of stepping over them.

Casey Lartigue is a member of the black leadership network Project 21 and the host of the blog "What Would You Say If You Weren't Afraid?" (located on-line at http://www.caseylartigue.blogspot.com). Comments may be sent to caseylartigue@yahoo.com.

CJL

Popular posts from this blog

Let's not shake hands (Korea Times, July 2, 2014) by Casey Lartigue, Jr.

Let's not shake hands By Casey Lartigue, Jr. While there are many things that I love about Korea, there are two things that drive me crazy. One is that, in my observation, most Korean men don't wash their hands after using the bathroom. I know some people get defensive about non-Koreans commenting in a negative way about Korean culture and life, that they want to attack the messenger and the messenger's native country. So I will start by clearly stating that many men in America don't wash their hands either. According to the Website  Stop Handshaking , while 92 percent of adults in America say they wash their hands in public restrooms, an observational study of 6,076 adults sponsored by the American Society for Microbiology (ASM) found that only 66 percent of men actually washed their hands in public restrooms (88 percent of women did so). As an aside, I am curious how they "observed" that many peopl...

Radio, Harvard

I'll be a guest on XM 169 The Power this morning from 10:15 a.m. EST. I'll be talking about teaching English abroad. I'll be interviewed by Brian Higgins of MYB Talk . I sang last night for about five hours with friends but I'm sure my voice will be fine. Tuesday, I'll be interviewed by a Harvard University representative who wants my input on a new doctoral program for education leaders . It is a collaboration between the Harvard Graduate School of Education, the Harvard Business School and the Harvard Kennedy School. Some folks at the Booker Rising site are (again) reminding me that I'm not as smart as I think I am. CJL

Park Jin welcoming remarks to FSI (and Casey Lartigue)

  National Assembly member Park Jin makes the welcoming remarks at FSI's conference featuring North Korean diplomats. Park Jin | Greeting message to FSI and Casey Lartigue mention - YouTube

Mentoring while Black (Korea Times 2/16/2023)

  Mentoring while Black by Casey Lartigue Jr. February 16, 2023 www.patreon.com/caseylartigue

North Korean defector seeks justice (Korea Times)

  It was international news when 12 North Korean waitresses and a male manager who worked at a restaurant operated by the North Korean regime in China arrived in South Korea in 2016.  The waitresses have mostly maintained a low profile. There have been numerous accusations and assertions, with some saying the waitresses didn't want to escape, some accused the Park Geun-hye administration of playing politics by releasing details of the case, etc., etc., etc. My blog at the Korea Times today features an exclusive interview with one of the former North Korean waitresses who filed a criminal case against the former manager. You can read about it here on the Korea Times website. https://www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/opinion/2023/02/728_345165.html   Keep in mind that there are many more facts to the case and that it is much deeper than this brief excerpt of her comments. She also shared legal documents that I shared with the Korea Times well in advance to give them time to review t...