Skip to main content

Crazies Can Spoil a Movement (June 19, 2003 commentary)

Crazies Can Spoil a Movement

by Casey Lartigue, Jr.
At an anti-war "teach-in," a Columbia University professor called for the defeat of American forces in Iraq and said he would like to see "a million Mogadishus" - a reference to the Somali city where American soldiers were ambushed, with 18 killed, in 1993.

"The only true heroes are those who find ways that help defeat the U.S. military," Nicholas DeGenova, assistant professor of anthropology at Columbia University, told the audience at Low Library Wednesday night. "I personally would like to see a million Mogadishus."

The crowd was largely silent at the remark. They loudly applauded DeGenova later when he said, "If we really believe that this war is criminal... then we have to believe in the victory of the Iraqi people and the defeat of the U.S. war machine." (New York Newsday)

Some have remarked that the war brought out the nuts. I say they were always there.

It seems to be pretty typical of movements for the crazies to take over, outflanking the moderates. The moderates in any movement, especially those complaining that their voices aren't being heard, will not want to silence the dissenters among their own ranks.

I saw this happen in the various liberal social causes I used to participate in, where people complained about society stifling their voices or not recognizing their concerns. Then, those same folks bent over backwards to accommodate the radical nut in the room complaining that they - the people in the room - don't recognize the "reality of the situation." Yeah, we ain't gotta be afraid to speak "truth to power." All we gotta do is (fill-in-the-blank with something that won't work).

Then, they started a rambling ten-minute rant that makes some in the room uncomfortable but emboldened others. The leader meekly tried to cut the person off, waiting for the right moment instead of just telling them to sit down and shut up.

I don't hang out with conservatives when it comes to social causes, so I haven't observed them as much. But I'm sure they have their own crazies. I'm thinking of someone who stands up and says this country is great because of God, guns, and guts, and let's keep all three! And then, after a long tirade, will say, "Now I don't know exactly what we gotta do, but I know we gotta do 
sumpthin'."

There is a split (most recently, within the environmental and anti-abortion movements) between moderates who want to convince people to come to their side and the crazies who want to burn stuff down, spike trees and shoot doctors. As with most movements, the moderates gain early control. After a while, especially after some successes, the crazies will complain that things aren't progressing fast enough and that more radical action is needed. The moderates have already pushed for change, and they don't know how to push back when their crazies challenge them.

Groups don't want to shout down their own crazies because the crazies can still be useful foot soldiers. But then they do want to spend time focusing on the crazies of the other side.

Of course, the embarrassment is when one of the crazies gets up at a protest and starts pulling against the country on camera or when a crazy movie director dumps on the President during an internationally televised awards ceremony. The moderates will usually cheer the crazies on solidarity, but they worry they are undermining their message with such radical tactics.

Of course, I'm not saying it always plays out this way. I didn't pay close attention to the people outside of the U.S. Supreme Court as the justices inside debated the fate of affirmative action, but I bet it had a combination of intellectuals and activists. And at least one crazy stood up and talked about telling "truth to power" and saying all we gotta do is (fill-in-the-blank with something that won't work).

(Casey Lartigue, Jr. is a member of the National Advisory Council of Project 21 and an educational policy analyst with the Cato Institute. Comments may be sent to Project21@nationalcenter.org.)






 

Original Project 21 link

Popular posts from this blog

Let's not shake hands (Korea Times, July 2, 2014) by Casey Lartigue, Jr.

Let's not shake hands By Casey Lartigue, Jr. While there are many things that I love about Korea, there are two things that drive me crazy. One is that, in my observation, most Korean men don't wash their hands after using the bathroom. I know some people get defensive about non-Koreans commenting in a negative way about Korean culture and life, that they want to attack the messenger and the messenger's native country. So I will start by clearly stating that many men in America don't wash their hands either. According to the Website  Stop Handshaking , while 92 percent of adults in America say they wash their hands in public restrooms, an observational study of 6,076 adults sponsored by the American Society for Microbiology (ASM) found that only 66 percent of men actually washed their hands in public restrooms (88 percent of women did so). As an aside, I am curious how they "observed" that many peopl...

2019-02-18 TNKR media mentions coming soon

  We had two media interviews at our office today.  We also have some media outlets who will be covering our speech contest on Saturday, doing interviews before and after the contest. The two interviews today were with an international media outlet and a prominent Korean one. As usual, the international media outlet didn't want to commit to mentioning TNKR although 1) they had promised that when they first contacted us 2) we found an interviewee for them 3) organized it 4) hosted the interview. Update: Yes, NPR you are terrible, once again using non-profits for stories, then ignoring them when it is time for publication. NPR reporters blame their editors back at headquarters for choosing not to name organizations, I am now used to their process. So after this case, I decided when an NPR (or New York Times) reporter contacts me, I will ask the reporter if I can speak to their editor at the start. Perhaps I should also ask to speak to their mothers. www.lovetnkr.org/donate

2019-09-06 Interesting Person of the Week

  2019-09-06, I was the "Interesting Person of the Week" on TBSeFM, interviewed by former National Assembly member Jasmine Lee. We  first met about six years ago when she was in the National Assembly, but we lost contact a few years ago when I changed jobs and went through a cell phone change. We were in-studio, live on the air, for the “Interesting Person of the Week” feature on Jasmine Lee’s show, 10 Everyday. Podcast: https://audioclip.naver.com/channels/106/clips/12008 The main thing I liked about it: The interview was interactive. She wasn’t just interviewing by going down a list of questions, then jabbing at me occasionally. She had her own thoughts and experiences and would mention them within the context of what I was saying. When she introduced me, I was tempted to say, “If I’m so interesting, why did you wait to interview me? I didn’t get interesting until this week???” Well, even Michael Jordan wasn't MVP every year even though he is one of the all-time greats!...

2015-11-12 Case Study of TNKR by Columbia Teachers College

  --New York, New York-- If TNKR can make it here, it can make it anywhere... * Wanna know how good TNKR is? Even great people at Columbia University believe it is great. Teach North Korean Refugees is now being analyzed by graduate students at The Teachers College, Columbia University as part of a case study. TNKR wasn't even an official organization until May 2015, but we have already had many great things happen. With both the professor and students in the class analyzing us--yes, asking some pointed questions, too--then TNKR should be even stronger in 2016 in helping refugees find their way and tell their stories. * Have you ever told someone that you were honored by something they were doing, and they try to convince you that they are even more honored to collaborate with you! That's what happened tonight with the professor at Columbia University who opened her classroom to me. She and the students were asking me plenty of pointed questions about TNKR. Based on their respo...

Paperwork versus real work

  Yes, we have fun at Freedom Speakers International! So much fun that some people seem to be surprised to learn that we are an official organization requiring an actual budget, are accountable to our donors and sponsors, and must keep accurate records of our activities. Freedom Speakers International (FSI) has been officially registered as a 501(c)3 tax-deductible organization with the IRS in the USA since mid-2017, and we have had similar status in South Korea since 2016 (tax deductions for individuals, not corporations). And being an official organization means we spend a lot of time on paperwork instead of real work! In the photo, you can see the mountain of paperwork that FSI co-founder Eunkoo Lee and FSI accountant Sharon Jang have kept track of and had me sign today.  My role: being the rascal coming up with the projects and activities causing so much paperwork, then signing it all when they corner me. * * * Some people used to ask why we needed money because we had vol...