Skip to main content

Crazies Can Spoil a Movement (June 19, 2003 commentary)

Crazies Can Spoil a Movement

by Casey Lartigue, Jr.
At an anti-war "teach-in," a Columbia University professor called for the defeat of American forces in Iraq and said he would like to see "a million Mogadishus" - a reference to the Somali city where American soldiers were ambushed, with 18 killed, in 1993.

"The only true heroes are those who find ways that help defeat the U.S. military," Nicholas DeGenova, assistant professor of anthropology at Columbia University, told the audience at Low Library Wednesday night. "I personally would like to see a million Mogadishus."

The crowd was largely silent at the remark. They loudly applauded DeGenova later when he said, "If we really believe that this war is criminal... then we have to believe in the victory of the Iraqi people and the defeat of the U.S. war machine." (New York Newsday)

Some have remarked that the war brought out the nuts. I say they were always there.

It seems to be pretty typical of movements for the crazies to take over, outflanking the moderates. The moderates in any movement, especially those complaining that their voices aren't being heard, will not want to silence the dissenters among their own ranks.

I saw this happen in the various liberal social causes I used to participate in, where people complained about society stifling their voices or not recognizing their concerns. Then, those same folks bent over backwards to accommodate the radical nut in the room complaining that they - the people in the room - don't recognize the "reality of the situation." Yeah, we ain't gotta be afraid to speak "truth to power." All we gotta do is (fill-in-the-blank with something that won't work).

Then, they started a rambling ten-minute rant that makes some in the room uncomfortable but emboldened others. The leader meekly tried to cut the person off, waiting for the right moment instead of just telling them to sit down and shut up.

I don't hang out with conservatives when it comes to social causes, so I haven't observed them as much. But I'm sure they have their own crazies. I'm thinking of someone who stands up and says this country is great because of God, guns, and guts, and let's keep all three! And then, after a long tirade, will say, "Now I don't know exactly what we gotta do, but I know we gotta do 
sumpthin'."

There is a split (most recently, within the environmental and anti-abortion movements) between moderates who want to convince people to come to their side and the crazies who want to burn stuff down, spike trees and shoot doctors. As with most movements, the moderates gain early control. After a while, especially after some successes, the crazies will complain that things aren't progressing fast enough and that more radical action is needed. The moderates have already pushed for change, and they don't know how to push back when their crazies challenge them.

Groups don't want to shout down their own crazies because the crazies can still be useful foot soldiers. But then they do want to spend time focusing on the crazies of the other side.

Of course, the embarrassment is when one of the crazies gets up at a protest and starts pulling against the country on camera or when a crazy movie director dumps on the President during an internationally televised awards ceremony. The moderates will usually cheer the crazies on solidarity, but they worry they are undermining their message with such radical tactics.

Of course, I'm not saying it always plays out this way. I didn't pay close attention to the people outside of the U.S. Supreme Court as the justices inside debated the fate of affirmative action, but I bet it had a combination of intellectuals and activists. And at least one crazy stood up and talked about telling "truth to power" and saying all we gotta do is (fill-in-the-blank with something that won't work).

(Casey Lartigue, Jr. is a member of the National Advisory Council of Project 21 and an educational policy analyst with the Cato Institute. Comments may be sent to Project21@nationalcenter.org.)






 

Original Project 21 link

Popular posts from this blog

Forgery or conspiracy? Memorandum 46

Here's an article I co-wrote that will appear in the Sunday Outlook section of the Washington Post . We'll be updating this page over the coming days. So check back for updates. Memorandum 46 timeline , as compiled by us. Audio from our last show on XM 169 before we got fired. That audio is divided into segments, this one is one large MP3 . Who says Memorandum46 is true? Former rep. Cynthia McKinney presents Memo 46 to the United Nations and defends it in a speech . Joe Madison presents Memo 46 at the annual Congressional Black Caucus gathering. Former D.C. delegate Walter Fauntroy, on the Joe Madison show on XM 169 (audio available, upon request) and on Michael Fauntroy's site Boyd Graves (see Exhibit 10 of his lawsuit against the government) The Final Call, with Brzezinski's name misspelled . Len Horowitz Blackelectorate.com Millions for Reparations Various discussion forums or discussants, such as: Greekchat , Jahness , Who says Memorandum 46 is a forgery? Brzezi

The Casey Lartigue Show

Guests scheduled for May NOTE: Check here for updates on Memorandum 46! Future Shows Thomas Sowell of the Hoover Institution This is my first attempt at putting together my own promo , it was rejected because of the sound quality May 19 edition of the Casey Lartigue Show We had a great show yesterday, probably the best so far. The topic: Malcolm X. The occasion? Anniversary of his 82nd birthday. Eliot Morgan and I had a great time talking with the callers. Deneen Borelli called in on our special guest line. You can download the file here. We posed the question: What did Malcolm X do? We contrasted the viewpoint and legacies of Malcolm X and Thurgood Marshall. The one mistake I made was not to focus on the question that Marshall asked: What was the one concrete thing that Malcolm X did. In segment 3, callers begin to get personal with us. May 12 edition of the Casey Lartigue Show Featured guest: Don Boudreaux of George Mason University Promo for the May 12 show May 5 edition of the C

Park Jin welcoming remarks to FSI (and Casey Lartigue)

  National Assembly member Park Jin makes the welcoming remarks at FSI's conference featuring North Korean diplomats. Park Jin | Greeting message to FSI and Casey Lartigue mention - YouTube

2016-11-03 Who is Andrei Lankov?

Disclaimer: NK experts, please don't read this, there will be no rabbits pulled out of a hat. * * * Every couple of months, I meet up with Andrei Lankov to discuss various things. I first met him back in 2011, shortly before he spoke at an event I organized with the Center for Free Enterprise. I have read his articles for years, he has spoken at about four TNKR events over the years. When it comes to analyzing NK, he is one of the leading experts in the field. Last March, I was one of the organizers of the first (and perhaps last) International Volunteers Workshop, we had 227 RSVP in advance. I asked them all as part of the RSVP: "The keynote speaker will be Andrei Lankov. Had you heard of him before hearing about this event?" No: 133 Yes: 94 Even within those 94 "Yes" responses, I am sure there were various levels of awareness--such as some may have seen his name, others may have read some articles, and a few experts may have the Andrei La

Songmi’s first book signing (2022-09-27)

Songmi Han escaped from North Korea in March 2011 and was released into freedom in South Korea in October 2011. For the first decade, she was silent. She was struggling with settling down and was also a survival of several different traumas. After she went through counseling and joined Freedom Speakers International as a Special Assistant in early 2021, she finally began to open up. I suggested that she might want to write a book. that her healing process might also be able to help others. After some discussions, she decided to try, although she recruited me as her co-author (that was NOT part of my suggestion). As we worked on the book, I told her that the would come that she would have a book signing. She didn’t believe it. Eighteen months later, she had her first in-person book signing. I organized a trip to the USA, with the first event being held on her birthday. Below are many of the photos I took of her as she signed books with attendees in Nashville. Finally, after signing many