Skip to main content

Harvard admissions process (The Korea Times)

Harvard admissions process 

(Korea Times, November 9, 2012)

By Casey Lartigue, Jr.

Outstanding Korean students who are now agonizing over the college admissions process at top North American universities should take a moment to curse Abbott Lawrence Lowell, president of Harvard University from 1909 to 1933.

Concerned that there were too many Jewish students at Harvard, Lowell first tried to implement a quota. Later, he and the Harvard Board of Overseers agreed on a more subjective standard that included recommendations, interviews, and “geographic diversity” (thus, reducing the number of Jewish students from New York).

The admissions process that is so common today has a sordid history ― and it bedevils Korean students applying to Harvard and other top universities. A few years ago when I looked into the statistics, about 5 percent of Korean students who apply to Harvard College were getting accepted (compared to about 7-8 percent overall for others).

Although I am a graduate of the Harvard Graduate School of Education who declared at graduation that “I’m done with school,” I recently joined a conference call with the dean of admissions at the Harvard Graduate School of education from Cambridge and interested people here in Seoul. I joined because so many Koreans ask me for tips about getting into Harvard. I wasn’t surprised by the response that the admissions dean at the Harvard Graduate School of Education gave to my question: What’s the most common mistake that Korean students make when they apply to Harvard?


He highlighted two main issues that would have delighted Lowell. One is the Statement of Purpose. That’s the short essay where students are given the chance to brag about themselves. As the dean noted, by the time a student is applying, it is too late to do much to change grades, test scores and experience. Students do have control over the Statement of Purpose to explain what they can contribute, how they can make a difference and what can make them attractive to Harvard.

My guess is that while that applies to students overall, it is a special problem because for so many years Korean students have been test taking machines, getting their essays polished by tutors and essay specialists. Based on the essays I have seen, their Statements of Purpose read like a “spec” tour from hagwon to hagwon, a checklist that doesn’t add up to much. The lessons learned sound all too similar, fitting within a format developed over the years by tutors and experts.

A second problem the admissions dean mentioned: recommendations. It isn’t enough to have a recommendation from someone famous or even someone who went to Harvard. The reference should know the person. Back when I was at Harvard, I heard a story, perhaps an urban legend, about a student who had a recommendation from a former U.S. president, who signed something like, “Casey Lartigue is an outstanding young man, I’m sure he will do well in life,” and signed his name.

That doesn’t explain to Harvard (or any university) why you will offer something different (although it would be interesting to have a reference from the U.S. president). They are looking for a recommendation that lets them know why you are special and why you are likely to proudly represent the university.

The admissions dean may not agree with this point I would tell my students when I was a college counselor a few years ago: Recognize that the admissions game is a game. The Harvard process, and that of other universities, is not logical or scientific. Volunteering at a soup kitchen is apparently more valued than working at Pizza Hut, although youngsters working at Pizza Hut are more likely to learn real skills about dealing with others, although you may feel better at a soup kitchen.

Certainly it is important to have good or great grades but the subjective process leaves a lot of discretion for admissions committees who don’t explain to students why they were rejected (and they don’t explain because students would quickly adapt). A rejection letter doesn’t mean you are unworthy of being at a top university ― it means, in the case of students with similar academic backgrounds competing for a handful of spots, that others played the admissions game better.

So that means that Korean youngsters who do desire to enter top universities and graduate schools in the U.S. need to have their own strategy to better position themselves. Of course there are no guarantees, even when you master the rules of the game. And for that, Korean students can thank Lowell for trying to reduce the number of Jewish students at Harvard nine decades ago.

The writer has a bachelor’s degree in the social sciences from the Harvard University Extension School and a master’s degree in administration, planning and social policy from the Harvard Graduate School of Education. He can be reached at caseyradio@daum.net.

Original Korea Times link November 9, 2012)

Popular posts from this blog

Walter E. Williams hosting Rush Limbaugh tomorrow

Check your local listings! By the way, my co-host Eliot Morgan and I interviewed Professor Walter E. Williams on the Casey Lartigue Show on April 28 and June 9 . We discussed reparations for slavery and the minimum wage mandate. To access the clips above at rapidshare: 1) scroll down to the bottom, hit the "free" button. 2) scroll down to the bottom, type in the password, hit download, then listen... Or, you can download the clips from yousendit, available for one week: June 9, WEW, segment 5 http://download.yousendit.com/F8A128C94CEAD09C June 9, WEW segment 6 http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.php?action=download&ufid=9800ABE6204647B3 April 28 http://download.yousendit.com/72FB5F4718BC06A1 CJL

Park Jin welcoming remarks to FSI (and Casey Lartigue)

  National Assembly member Park Jin makes the welcoming remarks at FSI's conference featuring North Korean diplomats. Park Jin | Greeting message to FSI and Casey Lartigue mention - YouTube

Forgery or conspiracy? Memorandum 46

Here's an article I co-wrote that will appear in the Sunday Outlook section of the Washington Post . We'll be updating this page over the coming days. So check back for updates. Memorandum 46 timeline , as compiled by us. Audio from our last show on XM 169 before we got fired. That audio is divided into segments, this one is one large MP3 . Who says Memorandum46 is true? Former rep. Cynthia McKinney presents Memo 46 to the United Nations and defends it in a speech . Joe Madison presents Memo 46 at the annual Congressional Black Caucus gathering. Former D.C. delegate Walter Fauntroy, on the Joe Madison show on XM 169 (audio available, upon request) and on Michael Fauntroy's site Boyd Graves (see Exhibit 10 of his lawsuit against the government) The Final Call, with Brzezinski's name misspelled . Len Horowitz Blackelectorate.com Millions for Reparations Various discussion forums or discussants, such as: Greekchat , Jahness , Who says Memorandum 46 is a forgery? Brzezi

2020-05-21 Goodbye, Katty Chi

I had heard through the grapevine and now it has been verified: Human rights activist Katty Chi has passed away. She is one of the first people that I met when I got involved in this cause. The first time was in 2012, at an event at the South Korea's National Assembly. She was super cool, one of my favorites as I used to say even when she was alive. And that is the important time to say such things, when people are alive. Whenever we met, I would say to her, "You know what happens when you meet me?" She would say, "Yeah. Time to take a photo?" I'm glad we did. And from Hyun S. Song, a close colleague of hers: And from Liberty in North Korea, the definitive announcement, August 4, 2020

2018-03-08 Challenge Korea Global Award

  I am so proud to be the recipient of the Challenge Korea Global Award. Today I attended the awards ceremony, held at South Korea's National Assembly. It is quite an honor. There are about 50 million people in South Korea, about 2 million of them are non-Koreans. Out of all of those people, I was one of the 10 people to receive an award today (the Global Award). I'm not a celebrity, singer, actor, politician or rich man. I am just a man struggling to build an NGO in a foreign country empowering North Korean refugees. These days, I rarely leave my office, so I'm not getting this kind of award because of networking. It is the second consecutive year that I've won an award, and last month TNKR (now FSI) was honored as a finalist for the Asia Liberty Award. Incredibly, we have received a lot of press even though we don't have anyone focused on reaching out to media. We get this kind of attention because of our good work. I'm not sure that I really deserve this awar